I can handle e-mailing up to 5 guys at a time comfortably; when I do more it feels insane. Now how many of those actually turn into dates, and how many of them get beyond 1 or 2 dates, is another issue. And just to be clear, I define e-mailing as when each person in the relationship has sent at least two e-mails.
2
JuJu
By “dates”, I suppose, we are assuming I already find their e-mails and photos and vital stats appealing enough to agree to a meeting, right?
In that case, on any given week of active internet dating, there would be around 3-5.
A-L is right, it’s difficult to handle communication with more people than that at a time – it practically becomes a second job. I start having problems remembering who is who and several times considered setting up some sort of a file system 🙂 – thank Gmail for grouping messages by thread.
3
Cilla
Agree with A-L. As I mentioned in a previous comment, I’m back on the market again and trying to decide how many men, if any, to contact at once. Realistically, I know that if I email 10 men, I’ll probably get 7 or 8 responses back, because I’m selective about whom I’m contacting. Do I really want to juggle 7 or 8 email conversations? Even if that’s manageable, do I want to deal with the 3-5 phone conversations that may result? I had enough trouble handling two guys at once this summer, with a third possibility who kept popping up! The pair-and-a-spare theory sounds nice for improving your stats, but it can make for a very busy schedule!
I’ll make it even more complicated for you. Because I’m in a position to move next year, I’m looking at long-distance relationships. I can date (without sex) several men simultaneously near home, but once you fly to someone else’s city, or they fly to yours, the expectations get raised. Of course, it’s permissible to say, “Sure come visit for the weekend, but you’ll stay in a hotel and they’ll be no sex,” but few guys will take you up on that offer. Or you can sleep with multiple guys during the same time period, but that gets tricky too, for all involved, and it’s not really comfortable for me. I made a relationship decision last summer quicker than I really wanted to because one of the men was 800 miles away. I really wanted to meet him, and I knew if we spent the weekend together, it would mean letting the other prospect go.
That long-distance relationship just ended (we decided to remain friends, so it wasn’t a total waste), but I’m regretting never having the chance to know that other guy who was in the running at the same time. Now, I will email fewer out-of-state men to begin with (maybe 2) and they’ll have to wait a little longer for a meeting, in case there’s anyone closer to home who might also fit the bill. Sorry! That’s the long way to say: 1 or 2 men out of state, 3 or 4 locally.
4
Karl R
One to two. Three is my max. I just don’t have that much time.
I expect that the ladies I correspond with aren’t necessarily under the same time constraints as I am, so they may exceed me.
5
LADY
I can handle at least 10 at one time. I eventually let go of those who are sucked into the “Online only” and into IM only. I prefer to talk on the phone.
I dont waste time for the face to face as I have learned so many lie as to thier appearance and it is a turn off when one lacks confidence ( Put up a pic older than 1 yr.)
So out of the 10 it boils down to 2 that have become good friends.
So I have decided no more online!! When my subscription ends in 2 weeks I am so done with it. I found most subscribers have been there for years, Darn scary thought!!!!
6
Jane
Actively emailing 3 or 4 men at a time. May meet for dates with 2 maybe 3. I find that things seem to sort themselves out over time as one man usually becomes the more comfortable and fun one to be with. I really trying to let things unfold and not rush to decisions.
I also like to talk on the phone prior to having an actual date. Sometimes it means I go no further.
7
Elli
I will email with 5-6 men at a time. Rather quickly I will decide if the man is someone I’d like to meet. I do not want to email for a prolonged period of time. When I was new to this, I could (and did) write over 50 pages (yes, you read that right) to a guy before meeting. Now, a few emails, a phone conversation or two and that’s it. Time to meet.
8
happygirl
I would say that I would email 3 max 4 at a time. Dating more then one person at a time. I can honestly say 2 maybe. I personally feel it I date more then 2 then I am not giving it a proper chance to develop.
9
Eathan
The most I’ve ever emailed is 8. Normally it’s around 4-5.
10
Lou
I once had 6 fisrt dates six nights in a row – and it was maddening and hard to keep track of everyone – so I limit myself now to maybe 3-5 at a time that I am in the process of seeing for the first time. Once that gets to second or third date territory – I cut down even further – figuring that if I am going on a third date – things are going well – otherwise why go on the third date?
Around 3-4, although it depends on the market at the time. These days I’m emailing exactly 1 gal, but when I was really dating around, I’d email as many as possible.
12
Dana
Five was always my limit. More than that and I’d just get confused and start calling them all by the wrong names.
13
Trisha
I’ve been online dating for a few years now and it was just standard to go on 3 to 4 dates each week. I added them in my phone with name, and something unique…their job, town they lived in, etc. I’ve decided the dating scene is great to get out and get to know someone. When you get to a stage where you would actually like to form a genuine and real relationship, you’ve got to get out of that mentality. Lately, I just go on 1 or 2 dates a month and prefer to meet someone who is interested in finding the right girl. It hasn’t been successful, but at least we’re both on the same page and no time is wasted with intentional one-daters.:)
14
Michael17
Usually 1–2. I will send out about 5–10 emails, and I will get perhaps 2–3 responses back. Out of those 2–3, maybe one will drop out, giving me 1–2.
15
Claudia
When you do online dating for quite awhile you get the hang of it. At first I was overwhelmed and emailed and dated my brains out – which is very confusing, and difficult to keep track of who’s who. Then I learned how to be more selective which the volume reduced. Now if a man seems good and he’s doing the right things to get and keep my attention, I’ll stick with him only to see what materializes. It doesn’t take long to end if nothing is going to happen. Then it’s on to another.
I haven’t met the man of my dreams yet, but there is always hope.
16
OnlineSucks
Jeez, I’ve been “online dating” for a month and I ALMOST was able to arrange a face-to-face…but then it fell through.
Not sure what I’m doing wrong, but I’m thinking there is a reason why I rarely date. Maybe I’m just “wired” that way? So far, it seems like online dating has all of the head aches of “non-online dating” only you have to wade through all of the B.S. just to freaking have a conversation.
Meh – I’ve just made the decision to cancel my membership. I’ve been happily alone for years now, and that is just the way I am.
16.1
anon
OLD was a fail for me too, got very little interest or response from men no matter what I did. I’ve been alone most of my adult life, it is what it is.
16.2
Marika
You know a month is no time at all in online dating? It’s like saying in preschool that you’re not going to be able to handle the final year of school exams and giving up at that point. I would give it at least 6 months of regularly going online, initiating contact and chatting / phone calls etc. (with some in person meetings of course) before you call it quits. (I would actually give it longer than that, but 6 months minimum would be reasonable).
First of all, I want to say that after reading all of your blog articles and your book, Why He Disappeared, I feel more empowered than ever in my dating…
Dear Evan, What’s the deal with engaging in e-mail conversation with women, things are going fine, and then out of nowhere, for no reason, they fall off the face of…
As you may know, before I became a dating coach, I was a prolific online dater. I tried every site around, starting in the late 90’s. Matchmaker.com. Nerve.com. JDate.com. Match.com.…
"Evan rocks as a dating coach, and if he can change my life, I promise: he can change yours, too!"
Thanks to Evan, I finally feel like I'm exactly where I want to be in life. The future is wide open and bright, and I found a rare gem to cherish. I thank Evan for his advice and insight, his reading recommendations, and his encouragement through this process!
"9 months and 14 first dates later, I met the man of my dreams! Love is not a big enough word for how we feel!"
It's only been 106 days, Evan, but they have been the BEST 106 days of my life! Thank you for leading me in the right direction, giving me the confidence to believe in myself and helping me find the love I deserve.
"Evan, you’re amazing. You’re changing a little corner of the world in a very special way."
The thing that I most love about Dan is that I can be myself around him. At 52 years old, I’ve never felt that way with any man I’ve dated… I believe that it’s just a matter of time before all of you beautiful women on here find someone special. Don’t give up!
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Feel free to opt-out in the cookie settings if you wish. ACCEPTCookie settings
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
I can handle e-mailing up to 5 guys at a time comfortably; when I do more it feels insane. Now how many of those actually turn into dates, and how many of them get beyond 1 or 2 dates, is another issue. And just to be clear, I define e-mailing as when each person in the relationship has sent at least two e-mails.
By “dates”, I suppose, we are assuming I already find their e-mails and photos and vital stats appealing enough to agree to a meeting, right?
In that case, on any given week of active internet dating, there would be around 3-5.
A-L is right, it’s difficult to handle communication with more people than that at a time – it practically becomes a second job. I start having problems remembering who is who and several times considered setting up some sort of a file system 🙂 – thank Gmail for grouping messages by thread.
Agree with A-L. As I mentioned in a previous comment, I’m back on the market again and trying to decide how many men, if any, to contact at once. Realistically, I know that if I email 10 men, I’ll probably get 7 or 8 responses back, because I’m selective about whom I’m contacting. Do I really want to juggle 7 or 8 email conversations? Even if that’s manageable, do I want to deal with the 3-5 phone conversations that may result? I had enough trouble handling two guys at once this summer, with a third possibility who kept popping up! The pair-and-a-spare theory sounds nice for improving your stats, but it can make for a very busy schedule!
I’ll make it even more complicated for you. Because I’m in a position to move next year, I’m looking at long-distance relationships. I can date (without sex) several men simultaneously near home, but once you fly to someone else’s city, or they fly to yours, the expectations get raised. Of course, it’s permissible to say, “Sure come visit for the weekend, but you’ll stay in a hotel and they’ll be no sex,” but few guys will take you up on that offer. Or you can sleep with multiple guys during the same time period, but that gets tricky too, for all involved, and it’s not really comfortable for me. I made a relationship decision last summer quicker than I really wanted to because one of the men was 800 miles away. I really wanted to meet him, and I knew if we spent the weekend together, it would mean letting the other prospect go.
That long-distance relationship just ended (we decided to remain friends, so it wasn’t a total waste), but I’m regretting never having the chance to know that other guy who was in the running at the same time. Now, I will email fewer out-of-state men to begin with (maybe 2) and they’ll have to wait a little longer for a meeting, in case there’s anyone closer to home who might also fit the bill. Sorry! That’s the long way to say: 1 or 2 men out of state, 3 or 4 locally.
One to two. Three is my max. I just don’t have that much time.
I expect that the ladies I correspond with aren’t necessarily under the same time constraints as I am, so they may exceed me.
I can handle at least 10 at one time. I eventually let go of those who are sucked into the “Online only” and into IM only. I prefer to talk on the phone.
I dont waste time for the face to face as I have learned so many lie as to thier appearance and it is a turn off when one lacks confidence ( Put up a pic older than 1 yr.)
So out of the 10 it boils down to 2 that have become good friends.
So I have decided no more online!! When my subscription ends in 2 weeks I am so done with it. I found most subscribers have been there for years, Darn scary thought!!!!
Actively emailing 3 or 4 men at a time. May meet for dates with 2 maybe 3. I find that things seem to sort themselves out over time as one man usually becomes the more comfortable and fun one to be with. I really trying to let things unfold and not rush to decisions.
I also like to talk on the phone prior to having an actual date. Sometimes it means I go no further.
I will email with 5-6 men at a time. Rather quickly I will decide if the man is someone I’d like to meet. I do not want to email for a prolonged period of time. When I was new to this, I could (and did) write over 50 pages (yes, you read that right) to a guy before meeting. Now, a few emails, a phone conversation or two and that’s it. Time to meet.
I would say that I would email 3 max 4 at a time. Dating more then one person at a time. I can honestly say 2 maybe. I personally feel it I date more then 2 then I am not giving it a proper chance to develop.
The most I’ve ever emailed is 8. Normally it’s around 4-5.
I once had 6 fisrt dates six nights in a row – and it was maddening and hard to keep track of everyone – so I limit myself now to maybe 3-5 at a time that I am in the process of seeing for the first time. Once that gets to second or third date territory – I cut down even further – figuring that if I am going on a third date – things are going well – otherwise why go on the third date?
Around 3-4, although it depends on the market at the time. These days I’m emailing exactly 1 gal, but when I was really dating around, I’d email as many as possible.
Five was always my limit. More than that and I’d just get confused and start calling them all by the wrong names.
I’ve been online dating for a few years now and it was just standard to go on 3 to 4 dates each week. I added them in my phone with name, and something unique…their job, town they lived in, etc. I’ve decided the dating scene is great to get out and get to know someone. When you get to a stage where you would actually like to form a genuine and real relationship, you’ve got to get out of that mentality. Lately, I just go on 1 or 2 dates a month and prefer to meet someone who is interested in finding the right girl. It hasn’t been successful, but at least we’re both on the same page and no time is wasted with intentional one-daters.:)
Usually 1–2. I will send out about 5–10 emails, and I will get perhaps 2–3 responses back. Out of those 2–3, maybe one will drop out, giving me 1–2.
When you do online dating for quite awhile you get the hang of it. At first I was overwhelmed and emailed and dated my brains out – which is very confusing, and difficult to keep track of who’s who. Then I learned how to be more selective which the volume reduced. Now if a man seems good and he’s doing the right things to get and keep my attention, I’ll stick with him only to see what materializes. It doesn’t take long to end if nothing is going to happen. Then it’s on to another.
I haven’t met the man of my dreams yet, but there is always hope.
Jeez, I’ve been “online dating” for a month and I ALMOST was able to arrange a face-to-face…but then it fell through.
Not sure what I’m doing wrong, but I’m thinking there is a reason why I rarely date. Maybe I’m just “wired” that way? So far, it seems like online dating has all of the head aches of “non-online dating” only you have to wade through all of the B.S. just to freaking have a conversation.
Meh – I’ve just made the decision to cancel my membership. I’ve been happily alone for years now, and that is just the way I am.
OLD was a fail for me too, got very little interest or response from men no matter what I did. I’ve been alone most of my adult life, it is what it is.
You know a month is no time at all in online dating? It’s like saying in preschool that you’re not going to be able to handle the final year of school exams and giving up at that point. I would give it at least 6 months of regularly going online, initiating contact and chatting / phone calls etc. (with some in person meetings of course) before you call it quits. (I would actually give it longer than that, but 6 months minimum would be reasonable).