Do You Have Unrealistic Expectations For Your Marriage?

Do You Have Unrealistic Expectations for Your Marriage?

This space has covered a lot of ground on passion vs. comfort.

I’m firmly in the camp that says passion is great, but there is no 40-year marriage based on passion. You NEED to have comfort.

So imagine my delight when I stumbled upon this article from a woman who has been married for 19 years and has redefined what is important to her over the course of time. At the beginning, it was exotic vacations and unrealistic expectations. Now, it’s something different, something far more meaningful. Says the author, Lisa Smith Molinari:

“We did not meet our original expectations, we’ve exceeded them. Back when we were dreaming of a life of romance uninhibited by responsibility, stress, and aging, we couldn’t fully comprehend the complexity and depth of the marital relationship.

What we didn’t understand then is that romance is more than candlelight dinners and adventurous travel. The foundation of long-term romance is really commitment, companionship and comfort.”

After all this time, do you still think that a lifetime relationship is based more on passion than on comfort?

And if so, where is the evidence for it?

Please read the original article here and share your thoughts below.

Join our conversation (42 Comments).
Click Here To Leave Your Comment Below.


  1. 1

    Going on seven years married here (no kids).   That article is right on, in every way that’s good.

  2. 2

    There’s a lot of ground  in between passion and comfort, and I haven’t been in a long term relationship as a mature 25 plus adult so I don’t really have much experience judging what’s realistic to expect. Of course, comfort and commitment sound great. But I’m looking for a lot more than snoozing off on the couch night after night in front of the tube. Not even sure if kids are for me, since I don’t really admire the harried, routined, romanceless lifestyles that I see   a lot of parents lead. I’m looking for a man who I have a deep personal and emotional connection with who inspires and challenges me spiritually, intellectually, and to be a better person (and I him) and is my partner on a number of wacky adventures. I recently rejected a string of men who I didn’t feel would be compatible with that vision, and am not so desperate to get married at 28 that I forgo everything just for comfort and security. I live a great single life and am not intent on having kids, so there’s no need to marry the first interested guy that comes along. When I was very young, I had several relationships with those nice types that treated me like gold but whom I had very little in common with in terms of our values and lifestyle and the security and comfort were just not worth the tradeoff. But am I expecting lots of sexual passion, flashy looks, money, and a “you just know” feeling? Definitely not.

  3. 3

    Most of unrealistic expectations are created by media, not only on the part of women, but on the part of men as well. Examples, Sex in the City, 50 Shades of Grey – a lot of reality shows that supposedly tell us how things are. Naturally, the more important things such as commitment, loyalty, stability take back seat to glamor, excitement, passion. After all, aren’t we all princesses waiting for our princes. Ahh, not really.  

    In a conversation with a 40 something year old girl friend of mine, when i asked her why she is single, she said she likes this one genius and normal men are not match for her. Well…she is 40 and still the same unrealistic expectations which in my opinion she is gonna be single for the long time. I told her, if he treats her nice, listens and tries that’s all she needs. Being a genius doesn’t mean he is going to make a good partner, husband or father. You were right all along Evan. It’s not the exterior that matters it’s the interior.

  4. 4
    Some other Steve

    Well she’s probably hot, which gives the relationship a much better chance of working out in the long term 😉

  5. 5

    and Some other Steve provides the flip side of unrealistic  expectations   expecting your partner to remain hot for the rest of your life….

  6. 6
    Karmic Equation

    Well, I was married for 9 years, engaged for 2 years before the marriage…and would still be married to my exhusband today if the criteria for a successful marriage were only “commitment, companionship and comfort.” My marriage met all three criteria, but it was still unsatisfying because, in the end, we lacked “appreciation” of each other. He took me for granted and I didn’t appreciate some of his efforts on my part.

    Her article anecdotally mentions appreciation, though–He appreciates her handiness with tools. She appreciates his sensitivity to her stretch marks.

    Add “appreciation” to the list and I would agree 100% with the article.

  7. 7

    Jenna #2: “I’m looking for a man who I have a deep personal and emotional connection with who inspires and challenges me spiritually, intellectually, and to be a better person (and I him) and is my partner on a number of wacky adventures.”
    With all due respect, Jenna, I find your list pretty good in terms of “unrealistic expectations” : ) There are probably 50 shades of unrealistic expectations, and you might find “more unrealistic” out there, but that does not make your requirements/expectations more realistic…
    After three LTRs, one lasting 7 years which is pretty much longer than the average marriage nowadays, I learned that you gotta choose your priorities and realize that the relationship might not continue as it started. Sure, you can run around your whole ilfe searching for that partner that would connect with you at all levels and follow you in all your adventures and believe that such scenario will last, or you can simply search for someone who loves you, is open-minded, adaptable, and loyal. It’s been my experience that developing a solid foundation of love, trust, respect, with the ability to challenge oneself and be adaptable is a better bet for connection and renewal through the years than looking for specifics and risking finding them but without the ability to adapt to life’s changing seasons.
    You may believe that what you want now is what you will want in 20 years, but it will likely change. Makes more sense to choose someone who can adapt and adjust to the unexpected with you, through the ebb and flow of life. It might mean that your guy would be a homebody nerd who would be accepting a out-of-his-comfort-zone adventure once in a while and staying home the rest of the time waiting for your return with open arms and a cup of fragrant tea. Might mean that you will be more curious spiritually and share most of these thoughts with friends instead of your life partner.
    After 17 months with my man, we’re right there. Cozyness, comfort, and acceptance of each other differences. I run around much more, while he stays home and have tea ready for when I return. But I do inspire him to more traveling, and he does inspire me to more movie watching : ) Ultimately I do desire a “boring” relationship that we can periodically infuse with some romance, and that’s exaclty what we are creating thanks to our creativity and sense of humor. And that feels pretty realistic to me for the long-term.

  8. 8

    Wow,  I wasted  my 15 minute work break on a useless piece of fluff.   Yes, at some point between 40 and 50 this is what women think, men on the other hand, look at the woman they married that has grown into the same comfort of grooming level  and decides that this is not what they signed up for, where is the hot 20 something I deserve after working my ass off for all these years…  Sorry Evan, you’re still in glorious newly married la-la land looking through rose-coloured glasses at your hopeful future on this one.  

    1. 8.1
      Evan Marc Katz

      @Jennbot – You’re entitled to your own opinion on the passion vs. comfort debate, but you can’t tell me MY opinion.

      If you’ve been reading me for awhile, you should know that I’ve NEVER been in rose-colored glasses, la-la land with my wife. I’ve always seen her quite clearly and been conscious of her flaws. And we’ve always had a comfortable, easy, supportive relationship like an old married couple – even when we first met. I found this challenging at the beginning: shouldn’t it be more tempestuous and passionate? But then I realized that the relationship I had was the one that was going to look like the one I wanted for the rest of my life. So I kept it. And I’m happy. And you can be, too, if you realize that the first two years of your relationship often bear very little relation to what happens after you buy a house, have kids, and get settled into a routine.

      I can’t guarantee that my wife and I will be together forever, because no one can guarantee anything, but I will say that I know exactly what I signed up for – and it looks a lot like the relationship in this article. That’s why I shared it with you. Sorry to have wasted your time.

  9. 9
    Jackie Holness

    Awww, that really sounds nice…but I do hope the sex is good between them…LOL…

  10. 10

    Awesome blog post, Evan. This is something I really had to evaluate for myself. I want a partner who I can first call my best friend because I want to still have something with him when the romance simmers down. Is it possible too that romance changes as the relationship progresses? For example, what was romantic in the beginning may not be as romantic later on?

  11. 11

    Fusee, trust me, I’m open to different types of men. I also mistakenly wrote down the interest of having someone challenge me intellectually – a man who I have interesting conversations with is enough. I’ve gotten along quite well with some blue   collar types – no college Ed required. Being well read also not required.  

    But for me, my offbeat adventurousness is one of the most exceptional,unique qualities I have and I can’t fathom being with a man who wasn’t up for trying new things large and small with me. This could be as small at times as joining each other for a hike somewhere new, or as big as taking a road trip across Russia or picking up and moving to peru for a year, or as simple as co hosting regular casual dinner parties where we invite a quirky mix of new and old friends. Luckily, there are men I meet who share that attitude. I’ve also met men who weren’t necessarily adventurous before we met, but had a try anything, up for anything attitude, and that was the important thing.  

    Just saying,   Depending on what’s important to you, you may want more than simply a nice commitment with a nice man. I accept that because my goal is not to live in the same suburban house for decades and have children and put career and travel and friends on the back burner and watch tv after dinner with my husband before dozing on the couch — not that those are your goals, fusee, I’m just thinking of many other women I know —   my dating process   and criteria will be different from those with other life goals.  

  12. 12

    IMO, there’s a time and a place for everything. A time to doze off on the couch, and a time to hitchhike across Russia (yikes, scratch that, I grew up there and I do not advise that! lol) As long as both parties believe in personal growth and like trying new things, it doesn’t have to be every day. There may be days, or even years, when they’re both too tired to do anything exciting. Which is fine, as long as they plan on getting back to it later, when they’re able. I have many friends whose kids are now grown and out of the house. Some of these couples take trips, try new activities, and go on adventures so amazing, just listening to them talk about it makes my head spin. Maybe that’s their idea of comfort — they feel that their work raising and educating their children is done, now they can relax, kick back and climb the Everest! Other couples just love the fact that the kids are gone and they can now relax, eat, drink, have friends over for drinks, and watch all the TV they want. Not my cup of tea, but if that’s what they like doing together, good for them. As long as the couple have each other’s back and work as a team through difficult years, I think they’ll be fine as a family. If they retain mutual trust, respect, and connection, then they’ll be able to figure out what constitutes comfort for them as a couple.

  13. 13

    Sweet article and can totally relate.   Sounds like Jennbot has some living and growing up to do.   Good luck!

  14. 14

    Marriage is so wonderful if both parties are equally committed, the problem lies when   one strays and thinks there is a better person out there and leaves. Anyone married to someone who believes in a lifetime of commitment is blessed and eventually all marriages do settle into routine, mine was 17 years and all that happened, it is about character and dedication to the institution of marriage that keeps people together in the long run. Anyone reading this who hasn’t had children should be informed that the children make the marriage more difficult and less romantic, not the other way around.  

  15. 15

    [email protected], I agree with much of what you said. I remember one season of Project Runway, where a contestant, (a mother of 6) was complimented on the classy attire that she wore on the show, and she replied ” it’s a slippery slope to sweat pants and a mini-van”. Aside from being a very funny comment, I think this is what people fear, that “comfort” means letting one’s appearance slide. That can be a passion killer, when one partner just lets it all go. I think with a little effort passion can be kept alive in some form. Romance evolves over time, but I don’t think we have to trade romance for long-term commitment. At least, I hope not.

  16. 16

    @ Jenna # 11:   I think the whole dating (as a woman) is drastically different when you are not hell-bent on having your own kids.   Somewhere around 35, I realized that I might NOT meet the right guy in time to procreate.   After that, I felt that an enormous weight had been lifted off my shoulders. I have seen too many women panic and marry *anyone* in order to have kids, and sadly end up as single mothers anyway.

    While I would have liked to have had at least one child, I  believe without a shadow of a doubt that I did not pass up anyone who would have made me happy.

    So much about  meeting and dating is luck and timing, and it doesn’t work out for everyone.   Yet, when I look at some of my friends and relatives and the men they are married to, I feel very fortunate indeed.

  17. 17

    I have very realistic expectations of marriage. Because I have NO expectations of marriage whatsoever. And if you’ve read my other comments, you know why…. 🙂

    1. 17.1

      they say men are happier in their marriages because they go in expecting to be less happy than when they were single. women go in expecting to be happier and live in a fairy tale, that’s why so many marriages are ended by the wife because you just can’t live a fairy tale for 30 or 40 years.    i don’t know if it is a fact or only beliefs but it makes sense to me

  18. 18

    Jennbot @8

    WOW, you also wasted a whole how many minutes? posting your zero value add comment on this ‘piece of fluff’.   I wasted a whole 40 seconds reading your guff and  five minutes getting the sh!ts enough to post this which took me another three minutes to type out.


  19. 19

    Great article!
    I guess I would have liked to have known more about their life – how is their sex life, how do they look? is her husband happy?
    I also wonder if men want that as well…

  20. 20

    In my experience as a 55+ woman and observing my friend’s marriages I would say nearly all so-called “good” marriages morph into “commitment, companionship and comfort” after 20 years or so.

    The problem is communication and the unwillingness of most couples to keep working the romance angle (date nights, flowers, etc.). Time and again I see most men unable to understand what their wives truly want and need  (and some vice versa). After 20 years or so, due to attachment (google)  (which men seem more prone to  than romantic love) men will stay with less than perfect women, but women? Well, if the children are grown and they  have the resources (and sometimes when they do NOT), they are now jettisoning their husbands in their fifties and sixties. Stats back me up on this: Most divorces are initiated by women after age 50.  Lots of celeb couples experiencing this now- the Gores, etc.

    I think I waited for my mother to lapse into a kind of slight dementia brought on by Parkinsons before I made my move. One day I entered her assisted living and despite being 91 overheard a quiet phone call and said “You getting divorced?” lol

    My dealbreaker was 20 years of being unappreciated and never told I was 1) smart, 2) capable,  or 3) had good ideas.    So I agree with Karmic. Appreciation is key and incidentally  studies show the chief reason men stray is feeling unappreciated at home.   I was his cheerleader, but he was not mine in the way I needed (his compliments were always about my appearance which got old. I also begged him to BE my cheerleader three times in the marriage but he wouldn’t change, said “I am no cheerleader Ellen”).    Listen, you NEED a cheerleader  when you have to deal with unemployment, and children, and difficult relatives and an autistic child. Not to mention all the petty indignities life throws your way…    

    Still I count my 25 year old marriage as a success in that I was loyal for many years and a good mother and wife. We made it work, in our fashion, for 25 years. Btw, I feel we put too much emphasis on “making it to the goalline- marriage til death” when that, imo, is  da*ned near impossible given our formidable lifespans now.

    No, right now I’m enjoying romance again and true love and appreciation for the first time since my 20s. It is extraordinary and I am one lucky girl indeed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *